Tony's Pizza New York Style has proudly served the finest pizzas and Italian dishes for over 31 Years to the Crescent Beach and Saint Augustine area!

In this day and age, it is nearly impossible to find a truly authentic New York Style pizzeria with all the pretenders out there serving bland, frozen "pizza." However, fear not! Tony's Pizza only uses fresh, quality ingredients in our made-from-scratch meals.

At Tony's Pizza, all of the sauces, dough, and meals are expertly crafted with care from scratch using old family recipes, and Tony has followed a long tradition of serving only the best to his customers, family, and friends. This, paired with Tony's belief that the customer always comes first, brings the authentic New York Style Italian pizzeria and eatery to the First Coast of Saint Augustine, Florida!

Tony not only cooks with the freshest ingredients, but Tony's Pizza does not serve, and will never serve, yesterday's leftovers! Every hour, extra large pies for pizza by the slice are made fresh! As Tony always says, "Only the finest for my friends! Only the finest!"

MENU INCLUDES:
-----------------------
PIZZA MENU
- Build Your Own Pizza
Toppings:
- MEAT
Pepperoni ● Meatballs ● Beef Sausage ● Beef ● Salami ● Anchovies ● Ham ● Canadian Bacon
(Turkey, Ham & Beef Pepperoni Available)
(Split toppings are double size and charged accordingly)

- VEGGIES
Extra Cheese ● Mushrooms ● Onions ● Green Peppers ● Black Olives ● Green Olives ● Fresh Garlic ●
Pineapple ● Broccoli ● Spinach ● Ricotta Cheese
(Split toppings are double size and charged accordingly)

- SPECIALTY PIZZAS
Supreme
Cheese ● Pepperoni ● Mushrooms ● Onions ● Green Peppers ● Beef Sausage

Super Supreme
Cheese ● Pepperoni ● Mushrooms ● Onions ● Green Peppers ● Beef Sausage ●
Meatballs ● Black Olives ● Salami ● Extra Cheese

Vegetarian Supreme
Cheese ● Black Olives ● Mushrooms ● Onions ● Green Peppers ● Green Olives ●
Fresh Garlic ● Fresh Tomato

White Pizza “The Healthy Heart Pizza”
Ricotta ● Mozzarella ● Parmesan

Greek Pizza
Black Olives ● Feta Cheese / Gyro

Sicilian (One Size – 16″)

Pizza by the Slice (till 5PM)
----------------------------------
- CALZONES
Standard Calzone
All calzones come with Parmesan, Ricotta & Mozzarella Cheese

Ham, Salami, & Cheese Calzone

Vegetarian Calzone

Chicken Calzone

Steak & Onions Calzone

Stromboli
Stuffed with Pepperoni, Sausage, Mozzarella Cheese, and a side of Marina Sauce (No Ricotta)
--------------------------------------
- PASTA DINNERS
Ravioli

Baked Lasagna

Baked Manicotti

Eggplant Parmigiana
Served with a side of Spaghetti

Chicken Parmigiana
Served with a side of Spaghetti

Spaghetti & Meat Sauce

Spaghetti & Meatballs

Spaghetti Supreme

Ziti with Meat Sauce

Ziti with Meatballs

Ziti Supreme

Stuffed Shells
-----------------------------
- SUB SANDWICHES
Meatball Sub

Pizza Sub

Super Sub
Ham ● Salami ● Cheese

Tony’s Ryder
Salami ● Turkey ● Ham ● Mozzarella Cheese ● Lettuce ● Mayo ● Fresh Tomato ● Mustard

Chicken Sandwich
Breaded Chicken on a Sub

Eggplant Parmigiana

Chicken Parmigiana

Turkey Sub

Veggie Sub

Steak & Onions Sub
------------------------------
- SALADS
Regular Salad with Meal

Large Salad to Go

Greek Salad

Antipasto Salad
Ham ● Salami ● Pepperoni ● Mushrooms ● Black Olives ● Cheese ● Italian Dressing
---------------------------------
- APPETIZERS & SIDES
Italian Chicken Wings
8 Hot Wings with hot sauce and Garlic bread

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks

Fresh Jalapeno Poppers

Garlic Bread W/ Cheese

Garlic Bread

Garlic Knots (12 count)
-----------------------------------


Thank You & Bon Appetit!

Local

Eat and Drink

• Tony's Pizza - New York Style - SAINT AUGUSTINE (0.0 miles) - Tony's Pizza New York Style has proudly served the finest pizzas and Italian dishes for over 31 ...
• Salt Life Food Shack - St. Augustine (6.3 miles) - We offer a carefully crafted eclectic menu to cater to all tastes and personalities. We provide the ...

See and Do

• Colonial Experience of St. Augustine St. Augustine (9.6 miles) - The Colonial Experience of St. Augustine is a historical attraction located at the Colonial Quarter ...
• The St. Augustine Pirate & Treasure Museum St. Augustine (9.6 miles) - Immerse yourself in an interactive, emotional high sea adventure and explore the Golden Age Of Pirac...
• St. Augustine Wild Reserve Saint Augustine (20.1 miles) - The St. Augustine Wild Reserve offers 2-hour walking tours on Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays at 2...
• Wet Cat APB, Inc St Augustine (22.0 miles) - Wet Cat Boats offers jet-powered kayaks to rent for enjoying the scenery of the St. Augustine, Flori...
• Sea Serpent Tours St Augustine (24.2 miles) - Sea Serpent Tours offers an amazing experience of viewing the shallow waters of the St Johns River a...